iPhone 17 Pro Max Review: 9.0/10 - Refined, Not Reinvented, and That's Okay
Overview
The iPhone 17 Pro Max is Apple’s most polished phone yet, but it’s also the least surprising flagship upgrade in years. The headline changes - a new Capture Button, a slightly larger display, and the A19 Pro chip - are meaningful refinements rather than generational leaps. Starting at $1,199, this is a brutally capable smartphone that finally fixes a few long-standing annoyances.
Design & Build
The titanium frame feels identical to the 15 and 16 Pro Max, which is to say it’s premium and reassuringly solid. The slightly larger 6.9-inch display means the phone grew a millimeter in height, but you won’t notice unless you put them side-by-side. The new Capture Button on the right edge is a dedicated camera shutter with half-press focus lock - it’s genuinely useful for one-handed shooting and feels like a proper camera control rather than a gimmick.
Performance
The A19 Pro is a monster. Geekbench 6 scores come in around 4,200 single and 17,500 multi - about 15% faster than the A18 Pro. What’s more impressive is the sustained performance; Apple’s thermal management has improved noticeably, and the phone barely throttles during extended gaming sessions. 12GB of RAM means tabs don’t reload, and ProRes video recording at 4K60 is now achievable without the phone turning into a hand warmer.
Features
The camera system is where the 17 Pro Max earns its keep. The new 48MP ultra-wide finally matches the main sensor’s resolution, giving you consistent color and detail across all three lenses. The 5x telephoto gets a larger aperture (f/2.4) for better low-light reach. Action mode at 4K60 is surprisingly stable - I shot B-roll running down stairs and it looked gimbal-smooth. Battery life is comfortably two days for moderate use, and the 40W wired charging (finally!) cuts top-up time significantly.
Pros
- Excellent camera consistency across all three lenses
- A19 Pro delivers class-leading performance
- Capture Button is genuinely useful for photographers
- 40W charging is a huge quality-of-life improvement
Cons
- Design is getting stale after three years
- Still ships with a cable and nothing else in the box
- 5x zoom lags behind Samsung’s 10x optical
- Very heavy at 227g
Verdict
The iPhone 17 Pro Max is the best iPhone you can buy, but it’s also the least exciting upgrade in recent memory. If you’re on a 14 Pro or older, the camera improvements and faster charging make the jump worthwhile. If you’ve got a 15 or 16 Pro Max, you can sit this one out without FOMO.
Ready to buy? Find the best price on eBay below.
As an eBay Partner we earn from qualifying purchases. Price may vary.
Technical Specifications
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this site, at no additional cost to you. We are a participant in the eBay Partner Network affiliate program. Our reviews remain independent and unbiased. Full disclosure.